Browse rules

Rule 39 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure

Trial by Jury or by the Court

Read Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 39, Trial by Jury or by the Court, from the December 1, 2025 edition.

39: Trial by Jury or by the Court

(a) WHEN A DEMAND IS MADE. When a jury trial has been demanded under Rule 38, the action must be designated on the docket as a jury action. The trial on all issues so demanded must be by jury unless:

(1) the parties or their attorneys file a stipulation to a nonjury trial or so stipulate on the record; or

(2) the court, on motion or on its own, finds that on some or all of those issues there is no federal right to a jury trial.

(b) WHEN NO DEMAND IS MADE. Issues on which a jury trial is not properly demanded are to be tried by the court. But the court may, on motion, order a jury trial on any issue for which a jury might have been demanded.

(c) ADVISORY JURY; JURY TRIAL BY CONSENT. In an action not triable of right by a jury, the court, on motion or on its own:

(1) may try any issue with an advisory jury; or

(2) may, with the parties’ consent, try any issue by a jury whose verdict has the same effect as if a jury trial had been a matter of right, unless the action is against the United States and a federal statute provides for a nonjury trial.

Federal Rules of Civil Procedure

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

The following selected judicial passages discuss Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 39: Trial by Jury or by the Court.

Ninth Circuit: mistakes and late demands

As in Beckham, the district court in the present case did not abuse its discretion in denying the demand because counsel inadvertently missed the deadline. A good faith mistake of law is no different than inadvertence or oversight. Therefore, an untimely jury demand due to legal mistake does not broaden the district court’s narrow discretion to grant the demand.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Fourth Circuit: broad discretion after waiver

Whereas the view that Rule 39(b) compels district courts to grant relief would present such a concern, see id., our view that the rule affords district courts broad discretion to grant relief takes the opposite approach. In so doing, it respects the balance struck by these interlocking rules, whereby a party must be afforded a jury trial if one is properly demanded, but takes his chances with the court’s discretion if not. And because a court may just as easily employ that discretion to deny an untimely request, a party who desires a jury trial remains incentivized to properly demand one.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Consent and a binding jury verdict

Thus, when both parties consent, Rule 39(c) invests the trial court with the discretion—but not the duty—to submit an equitable claim to the jury for a binding verdict. While the litigants are free to request a jury trial on an equitable claim, they cannot impose such a trial on an unwilling court.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

The best tool for reading complex documents. Use Eno free: no credit card, no subscription.