Browse rules

Rule 51 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure

Instructions to the Jury; Objections; Preserving a Claim of Error

Read Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 51, Instructions to the Jury; Objections; Preserving a Claim of Error, from the December 1, 2025 edition.

51: Instructions to the Jury; Objections; Preserving a Claim of Error

(a) REQUESTS.

(1) Before or at the Close of the Evidence. At the close of the evidence or at any earlier reasonable time that the court orders, a party may file and furnish to every other party written requests for the jury instructions it wants the court to give.

(2) After the Close of the Evidence. After the close of the evidence, a party may:

(A) file requests for instructions on issues that could not reasonably have been anticipated by an earlier time that the court set for requests; and

(B) with the court’s permission, file untimely requests for instructions on any issue.

(b) INSTRUCTIONS. The court:

(1) must inform the parties of its proposed instructions and proposed action on the requests before instructing the jury and before final jury arguments;

(2) must give the parties an opportunity to object on the record and out of the jury’s hearing before the instructions and arguments are delivered; and

(3) may instruct the jury at any time before the jury is discharged.

(c) OBJECTIONS.

(1) How to Make. A party who objects to an instruction or the failure to give an instruction must do so on the record, stating distinctly the matter objected to and the grounds for the objection.

(2) When to Make. An objection is timely if:

(A) a party objects at the opportunity provided under Rule 51(b)(2); or

(B) a party was not informed of an instruction or action on a request before that opportunity to object, and the party objects promptly after learning that the instruction or request will be, or has been, given or refused.

(d) ASSIGNING ERROR; PLAIN ERROR.

(1) Assigning Error. A party may assign as error:

(A) an error in an instruction actually given, if that party properly objected; or

(B) a failure to give an instruction, if that party properly requested it and—unless the court rejected the request in a definitive ruling on the record—also properly objected.

(2) Plain Error. A court may consider a plain error in the instructions that has not been preserved as required by Rule 51(d)(1) if the error affects substantial rights.

Federal Rules of Civil Procedure

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

The following selected judicial passages discuss Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 51: Instructions to the Jury; Objections; Preserving a Claim of Error.

Civil plain-error review

We now join our sister circuits and hold that, when reviewing civil jury instructions for plain error, we must consider, as we do in the criminal context, whether (1) there was an error; (2) the error was obvious; and (3) the error affected substantial rights. See Johnson, 520 U.S. at 466–67; Olano, 507 U.S. at 732. The text of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 51(d)(2), which bears a significant resemblance to the text of Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 52(b), supports this standard.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Specific objections and contextual assurances

Furthermore, as noted above, New Breed did in fact object to the language of the punitive damages instructions—though not to the absence of the good-faith affirmative-defense language. Thus, one can strongly infer that New Breed did not interpret the district court’s statement to mean that New Breed did not have to raise each of its objections during the charge conference. Therefore, the record reflects that New Breed did acquiesce to the punitive damages instructions.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Exceptional review of an unpreserved legal question

In addition to being novel, the punitive damages question is important and appears likely to recur in § 1983 litigation against municipalities. And here the question was squarely presented and decided on a complete trial record by the court of first resort, was argued by both sides to the Court of Appeals, and has been fully briefed before this Court. In light of all these factors, we conclude that restricting our review to the plain-error standard would serve neither to promote the interests of justice nor to advance efficient judicial administration. We therefore turn to the merits of petitioner’s claim.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

The best tool for reading complex documents. Use Eno free: no credit card, no subscription.